MMI - MMI Holdings Limited - Proposed restructuring of the existing broad-based18 May 2012
MMI
MMI                                                                             
MMI - MMI Holdings Limited - Proposed restructuring of the existing broad-based 
Black Economic Empowerment transaction                                          
MMI Holdings Limited                                                            
(Incorporated in the Republic of South Africa)                                  
(Registration number 2000/031756/06)                                            
JSE share code: MMI NSX share code: MIM                                         
ISIN: ZAE000149902                                                              
("MMI" or "the Company")                                                        
PROPOSED RESTRUCTURING OF THE EXISTING BROAD-BASED BLACK ECONOMIC EMPOWERMENT   
("BEE") TRANSACTION BETWEEN MMI HOLDINGS LIMITED ("MMI") AND KAGISO TISO        
HOLDINGS PROPRIETARY LIMITED (RF) ("KTH"), PROPOSED ODD-LOT OFFER AND VOLUNTARY 
REPURCHASE OFFER                                                                
1. RESTRUCTURING OF THE EXISTING BEE TRANSACTION                                
1.1 Introduction                                                                
MMI and KTH have a long-standing relationship, which began in 2004 when Kagiso  
Trust Investments Proprietary Limited (now known as KTH following its merger    
with Tiso Group Proprietary Limited) acquired a 10% shareholding in MMI, through
Off the Shelf Investments 108 Proprietary Limited ("SPV"), and became MMI`s     
strategic empowerment partner ("BEE transaction").                              
MMI was created in 2010 pursuant the merger of Metropolitan Holdings Limited    
("Metropolitan") and Momentum Group Limited ("Momentum"), resulting in a        
substantially larger and more diversified financial services group. MMI supports
opportunities to improve its business and advance its BEE status in line with   
the philosophy of good corporate citizenship and in line with the philosophy of 
good corporate citizenship and the department of trade and industry`s broad-    
based black economic empowerment codes of good practice ("codes").              
Following the merger of Metropolitan and Momentum in 2010, KTH and the          
Metropolitan Empowerment Trust (the vehicle through which MMI management held an
indirect interest in MMI) together held approximately 8% of MMI`s total issued  
ordinary shares. The Metropolitan Empowerment Trust has since exited the BEE    
structure, and KTH has increased its effective shareholding in MMI.             
MMI, in line with the continued objective to advance its BEE status, intends to 
facilitate the refinancing of the BEE transaction through specific amendments   
which will result in a restructuring thereof ("BEE restructuring"). This        
announcement outlines the key details of the BEE restructuring.                 
1.2 Rationale                                                                   
BEE is one of MMI`s most important business imperatives and is in line with     
MMI`s strategic objectives. While KTH`s effective interest in MMI has increased,
the current beneficial BEE shareholding was reduced following the Metropolitan  
Empowerment Trust`s exit. Given that the lock-in restrictions on KTH`s holding  
of MMI ordinary shares as provided for in the current relationship agreement    
will expire in the near future, the empowerment credentials of MMI could be     
negatively impacted should KTH elect to sell its interests in MMI.              
MMI intends to facilitate the BEE restructuring through the refinancing of KTH`s
shareholding in MMI and the extension of the lock-in restrictions in relation to
KTH`s shareholding in MMI. Pursuant to this, MMI and KTH have entered into a    
revised relationship agreement to facilitate MMI`s empowerment credentials.     
1.3 Terms of the BEE restructuring                                              
Below are the principal terms of the proposed BEE restructuring:                
  Step 1:   Extension and amendment to Both the A3 SPV preference shares and    
          the terms of the A3 MMI    the A3 MMI preference shares will be       
preference shares and A3   extended for a period of 5 years and       
          SPV preference shares      the terms attaching to these shares        
                                    will be amended. The annual coupon          
                                    per share payable on the A3 MMI             
preference shares will be reduced to        
                                    R1.32 per share per annum from the          
                                    current R1.76 per share.                    
  Step 2:   Convert all A1 and A2 MMI  SPV will convert all the A1 and A2       
preference shares into MMI MMI preference shares held by it into      
          ordinary shares            MMI ordinary shares on a one-for-one       
                                    basis as set out in the terms and           
                                    conditions attaching to the A1 and A2       
MMI preference shares.                      
  Step 3:   Funding raised by SPV      SPV intends to independently raise       
                                    funding of up to R271 million by            
                                    issuing a new class of preference           
shares to external funders, which           
                                    funding will be utilised to redeem          
                                    the existing A1 SPV preference              
                                    shares.                                     
Step 4:   Redemption of the A2 SPV   SPV will sell such number of MMI         
          preference shares          ordinary shares as is required to          
                                    redeem all the A2 SPV preference            
                                    shares.                                     
Following the BEE restructuring KTH will hold a direct and indirect equity      
interest of approximately 7% in MMI mainly through 79 million ordinary shares   
and 34 million A3 MMI preference shares.                                        
1.4 Pro forma financial effects of the BEE restructuring                        
The table below sets out the unaudited pro forma financial effects of the BEE   
restructuring on earnings per share ("EPS"), headline EPS ("HEPS"), net asset   
value ("NAV") and tangible net asset value ("TNAV") per share assuming that the 
proposed BEE restructuring took place to its full extent for purposes of the    
income statement for the six-month period started 1 July 2011 and ended 31      
December 2011 and as at 31 December 2011 for purposes of the statement of       
financial position.                                                             
The unaudited pro forma financial effects are the responsibility of the         
directors of MMI and have been prepared for illustrative purposes only to       
provide information about how the BEE restructuring may have impacted MMI       
shareholders ("shareholders") on the relevant reporting date and because of its 
nature may not give a fair reflection of the group`s financial position, changes
in equity, results of operations or cash flows after implementation of the BEE  
restructuring or of the group`s future earnings. The unaudited pro forma        
financial effects have been prepared using accounting policies that are         
consistent with International Financial Reporting Standards ("IFRS") and in     
accordance with the accounting policies adopted by MMI.                         
                            Before          Pro forma                           
                          the BEE         after the BEE   % Movement            
                           restructuring   restructuring                        
EPS (cents)               54              53              -1.85               
  HEPS (cents)              54              54              0.00                
  NAV per share (cents)     1,532           1,492           -2.61               
  TNAV per share (cents)    730             724             -0.82               
Weighted average number   1,489           1,555           4.43                
 of shares in issue                                                             
 (millions)                                                                     
Notes:                                                                          
1.   Assuming that SPV converts 65.7 million MMI convertible, redeemable        
    preference shares into 65.7 million MMI ordinary shares, this will result   
    in the conversion of a R388 million preference share liability into equity. 
2.   The SPV converts the A1 and A2 MMI preference shares into MMI ordinary     
shares, resulting in a reduction of preference share dividends (accounted   
    for as finance costs) of R15 million. The impact of additional interest     
    income, and the related tax impact, is negligible and has been ignored for  
    these purposes. No adjustment was made to dividends paid on MMI ordinary    
shares. This also results in the basic weighted average number of MMI       
    ordinary shares in issue increasing by 65.7 million shares.                 
3.   Assumes both the A3 MMI preference shares and the A3 SPV preference shares 
    are extended for a period of five years. The dividend rate per annum        
payable by MMI on the A3 MMI preference shares will be R1.32 per share,     
    resulting in a saving of R9 million in finance costs. The net impact of     
    interest income on this saving and the extension of the A3 SPV preference   
    shares, and the related tax impact, is negligible and has been ignored for  
these purposes.                                                             
4.   Transaction costs of R5 million (R1 million deferred tax) have been taken  
    into account.                                                               
1.5  Conditions precedent                                                       
The BEE restructuring is subject to:                                            
* the approval of all relevant resolutions in the notice of general meeting     
attached to the circular posted to shareholders today by the requisite majority 
of votes at the general meeting, which resolutions are required in order to     
effect the amendment to the terms attaching to the A3 MMI preference shares as  
detailed in the circular, and                                                   
* the lodgement of the relevant special resolutions with the Companies and      
Intellectual Property Commission.                                               
1.6 Fairness opinion                                                            
As the BEE restructuring involves the amendment of a previously approved BEE    
transaction and includes an extension of existing preference shares which are   
unlisted voting instruments, the Listings Requirements of the JSE Limited       
("JSE") require an opinion from an independent professional expert, confirming  
that the terms of the BEE restructuring are fair to MMI`s shareholders. Ernst & 
Young has been appointed by MMI as an independent expert and is of the opinion  
that the BEE restructuring is fair. Ernst & Young`s opinion is detailed in the  
circular posted to shareholders today.                                          
2. ODD-LOT OFFER AND VOLUNTARY REPURCHASE OFFER                                 
2.1 Introduction and rationale                                                  
Following the merger and the subsequent unbundling by FirstRand Limited         
("FirstRand") of its entire shareholding in MMI to FirstRand ordinary           
shareholders, MMI inherited a large number of minority shareholders, who each   
hold up to 500 MMI ordinary shares. On Tuesday 8 May 2012, MMI had a total of   
31,176 shareholders, of which approximately 4,915 shareholders (15% of all      
shareholders) held less than 100 MMI ordinary shares ("odd-lot holders") and an 
additional 12,898 shareholders (41% of all shareholders) held from 100 to 500   
MMI ordinary shares ("voluntary holders"). These shareholders hold approximately
2,915,526 MMI ordinary shares in aggregate, which constitutes approximately 0.2%
of the total number of MMI ordinary shares in issue.                            
In order to reduce the substantial and ongoing costs of administration connected
with a large number of odd-lot and voluntary holders, and to provide them with a
cost effective method of realising their investment in MMI, the Board is        
proposing the implementation of an odd-lot offer to repurchase the MMI ordinary 
shares of shareholders holding less than 100 MMI ordinary shares ("odd-lot      
offer") and a voluntary repurchase offer to repurchase the shares of            
shareholders holding from 100 to 500 MMI ordinary shares ("voluntary repurchase 
offer") (collectively, "the offers").                                           
2.2 Terms of the offers                                                         
In terms of the odd-lot offer, odd-lot holders are offered the opportunity to:  
* sell their odd-lot holdings at the offer price detailed below; or             
* retain their odd-lot holdings.                                                
Those odd-lot holders who do not make an election by no later than 12:00 on     
Friday 20 July 2012 ("record date"), will automatically be regarded as having   
chosen to sell their odd-lot holdings at the offer price.                       
In terms of the voluntary repurchase offer, MMI is extending an offer to        
voluntary holders to sell their entire shareholding at the offer price. Those   
voluntary holders who do not make an election by no later than 12:00 on the     
record date will retain their shareholding in MMI.                              
2.3 Shareholder information line                                                
Minority shareholders are encouraged to carefully read the circular and complete
the relevant election form. Any odd-lot or voluntary holder can contact the     
transfer secretary, Link Market Services South Africa Proprietary Limited on    
telephone +27 11 713 0894 from Thursday 7 June 2012 to Friday 29 June 2012      
between 09:00 and 12:00, excluding weekends and public holidays, for further    
information.                                                                    
2.4 Offer price                                                                 
The offer price will be calculated using the volume weighted average traded     
price of an MMI ordinary share on the JSE over the 5 trading days commencing on 
Thursday 28 June 2012 and ending on Wednesday 4 July 2012, plus a 10% premium   
("offer price"). The offer price will be announced on SENS on Friday 6 July 2012
and published in the South African and Namibian press on Monday 9 July 2012.    
2.5 Mechanism                                                                   
* The offers shall be open for acceptance from 09:00 on Thursday 7 June 2012 and
will close at 12:00 on Friday 20 July 2012. All shareholders who hold less than 
100 MMI ordinary shares at the close of business on the record date are invited 
to participate in the odd-lot offer, and shareholders who hold from 100 to 500  
MMI ordinary shares at the close of business on the record date are invited to  
participate in the voluntary offer.                                             
* The MMI ordinary shares of those odd-lot holders who do not make an election  
or who choose to receive the offer price will be repurchased by MMI. Any such   
repurchase will be regarded as an acquisition of shares under a specific        
approval in terms of the Companies Act, Act 71 of 2008 ("Companies Act") and as 
a specific repurchase of shares in terms of the JSE Listings Requirements.      
Shareholders will be required to exercise their votes to approve or not approve 
the odd-lot offer at the general meeting.                                       
* The MMI ordinary shares of those voluntary holders who choose to receive the  
offer price will be repurchased by MMI. Any such repurchase will be regarded as 
an acquisition of shares under a specific approval in terms of the Companies Act
and as a specific repurchase of shares in terms of the JSE Listings             
Requirements. Shareholders will be required to exercise their vote to approve or
not approve the voluntary offer at the general meeting.                         
* Odd-lot holders who do not make an election should note that, subject to the  
resolutions necessary to implement the offers being passed at the general       
meeting, their shares will automatically be repurchased by MMI, without any     
further action on their part and without any further notice to them.            
* Voluntary holders who do not make an election will retain their shareholding  
in MMI.                                                                         
2.6 Effect on share capital                                                     
The maximum number of shares that could potentially be repurchased by MMI if all
odd-lot and voluntary holders sell their holdings to MMI will not exceed        
2,915,526 shares. As the current issued share capital of MMI (prior to the      
implementation of the offers) comprises 1,503,985,331 shares as at 31 December  
2011, the repurchase of shares in terms of the offers will have no material     
effect on MMI`s issued share capital.                                           
2.7 Specific repurchase of shares and tax consequences thereof for shareholders 
selling their shares in MMI in terms of the odd-lot offer and voluntary         
repurchase offer                                                                
Below is a high-level summary of the potential tax consequences arising for     
shareholders who are odd-lot holders and voluntary holders in respect of the    
disposal of MMI ordinary shares by way of a specific share repurchase by MMI in 
terms of the offers. The summary of the tax implications serves as a general    
guide and is not intended to constitute a complete analysis of the tax          
consequences of the repurchase under South African tax law.  It is not intended 
to be, nor should it be considered to be legal or tax advice.  As each such     
shareholder`s personal circumstances may lead to a different tax analysis,      
shareholders should seek appropriate advice in respect of their particular      
circumstances from their personal tax advisors.                                 
In general, the cash consideration paid by MMI to shareholders pursuant to the  
specific share repurchase under the offers should constitute a "dividend" in the
hands of such MMI shareholders as no portion of the repurchase price will       
consist of contributed tax capital.                                             
The dividend should constitute an "exempt dividend" as contemplated in section  
10(1)(k)(i) of the Income Tax Act (unless one of the specific exclusions apply).
The dividend will, however, be subject to the withholding of dividends tax at a 
rate of 15 % (fifteen percent) of the dividend paid to the shareholder, unless a
specific exemption from dividends tax applies.                                  
2.8  Financial effects                                                          
The table below sets out the unaudited pro forma financial effects of the offers
on EPS, HEPS, NAV and TNAV per share assuming that the odd lot and voluntary    
repurchase offers took place to their full extent for purposes of the income    
statement for the six-month period started 1 July 2011 and ended 31 December    
2011 and as at 31 December 2011 for purposes of the statement of financial      
position.                                                                       
The unaudited pro forma financial effects are the responsibility of the         
directors of MMI and have been prepared for illustrative purposes only to       
provide information about how the offers may have impacted shareholders on the  
relevant reporting date and because of its nature may not give a fair reflection
of the group`s financial position, changes in equity, results of operations or  
cash flows after implementation of the offers or of the group`s future earnings.
The unaudited pro forma financial effects have been prepared using accounting   
policies that are consistent with International Financial Reporting Standards   
("IFRS") and in accordance with the accounting policies adopted by MMI.         
Before the      Pro forma      %                
                              offers          after the      Movement           
                                             offers                             
   EPS (cents)                  54              54             0.00             
HEPS (cents)                 54              54             0.00             
   NAV per share (cents)        1,532           1,531          -0.07            
   TNAV per share (cents)       730             728            -0.27            
   Weighted average number of   1,489           1,486          -0.20            
shares in issue (millions)                                                    
Notes:                                                                          
1. Assuming a maximum number of 2,915,526 MMI ordinary shares are repurchased in
terms of the offers, the financial cost is expected to be R56 million.          
2. All odd-lot offer shareholders and all voluntary holders are assumed to sell 
their odd-lot holdings (less than 100 shares) to MMI at the offer price,        
totalling R3 million.                                                           
3. The offer price assumed for pro forma purposes is R19.07. The impact of the  
offers results in a loss of interest income of R1 million on an assumed 5%      
interest rate (based on MMI`s actual average interest rate earned on cash during
the six months from 1 July to 31 December 2011) before tax (tax impact is       
negligible) and a reduction of 3 million in the weighted average number of      
shares.                                                                         
2.9 Conditions precedent                                                        
Subject to:                                                                     
* the requirements of section 48 (read with section 46) of the Companies Act,   
* to the special resolution authorising the specific repurchase in terms of the 
offers and the ordinary resolution authorising the directors to make and        
implement the odd-lot offer and the voluntary repurchase offer being passed by  
shareholders at the general meeting, and                                        
* the lodgement of the relevant special resolutions with the Companies and      
Intellectual Property Commission,                                               
all MMI ordinary shares sold by odd-lot holders and voluntary holders in terms  
of the offers will be repurchased by MMI as a specific share repurchase in terms
of section 48 (read with section 46) of the Companies Act and the provisions of 
the JSE Listings Requirements.                                                  
3. POSTING OF CIRCULAR AND NOTICE OF GENERAL MEETING                            
Shareholders are advised that in accordance with the JSE Listings Requirements, 
a circular incorporating a notice of a general meeting of shareholders has been 
dispatched to shareholders today, Friday 18 May 2012, containing full details of
the BEE restructuring and the offers. This Circular is also available on the MMI
website.                                                                        
The general meeting is convened to be held at MMI`s offices, 268 West Avenue,   
Centurion, on Monday 18 June 2012 at 12:00 for the purpose of obtaining the     
necessary approvals required to give effect to the proposed BEE restructuring   
and the offers.                                                                 
4. SALIENT DATES AND TIMES                                                      
The salient dates and times in respect of the BEE restructuring and the offers  
are as follows:                                                                 
                                             2012                               
Post circular                              Friday 18 May                      
  Last day to trade in order to be eligible  Friday 1 June                      
 to attend and vote at the general meeting                                      
  Offers open at 09:00                       Thursday 7 June                    
Record date to determine which             Friday 8 June                      
 shareholders are entitled to attend and                                        
 vote at the general meeting                                                    
  Proxy forms for the general meeting of     Thursday 14 June                   
shareholders to be received by transfer                                        
 secretaries by 12:00 (see note 3)                                              
  General meeting of shareholders to be held Monday 18 June                     
 at MMI`s registered offices at 12:00                                           
Results of the general meeting released on Monday 18 June                     
 SENS                                                                           
  Results of the general meeting published   Tuesday 19 June                    
 in the press                                                                   
Fulfilment of conditions precedent and     Friday 6 July                      
 finalisation of the offer price                                                
 announcement (including the final offer                                        
 price) released on SENS                                                        
Offer price announced in press             Monday 9 July                      
  Last day to trade in order to participate  Friday 13 July                     
 in the offer                                                                   
  Shareholders who purchase shares on or     Friday 13 July                     
after this date will not be eligible to                                        
 participate in offers                                                          
  Shares trade "ex" the offers               Monday 16 July                     
  Forms of election and surrender for the    Friday 20 July                     
offers to be received by transfer                                              
 secretaries by 12:00                                                           
  Offers close at 12:00                      Friday 20 July                     
  Record date to determine those             Friday 20 July                     
shareholders entitled to participate in                                        
 the offers at the close of business                                            
  Implementation of the offers takes effect  Monday 23 July                     
 after close of business                                                        
Odd-lot holders and voluntary holders with Monday 23 July                     
 dematerialised shares will have their                                          
 accounts held at their CSDP or broker                                          
 updated with their new holding and                                             
credited with the offer price                                                  
  Payments of the offer price to odd-lot     Monday 23 July                     
 holders and voluntary holders with                                             
 certificated shares in respect of their                                        
sale shares                                                                    
  Results of the offers released on SENS     Monday 23 July                     
  Results of the offers published in the     Tuesday 24 July                    
 press                                                                          
Notes:                                                                          
1.   These dates and times are subject to change and are indicated in South     
    African local time. Any material changes will be published on SENS and in   
    the press in South Africa and Namibia.                                      
2.   Share certificates may not be dematerialised or rematerialised between     
    Monday 16 July 2012 and Friday 20 July 2012, both days inclusive.           
3.   Any proxies not lodged by this time must be handed to the company          
    secretary/Link Market Services or to the person designated by the chairman  
in the alternate venue to be used for electronic participation in the       
    general meeting, if any, immediately prior to the general meeting.          
Centurion                                                                       
18 May 2012                                                                     
Merchant bank, transaction sponsor and debt advisor to MMI                      
Rand Merchant Bank (A division of FirstRand Limited)                            
Independent sponsor to MMI                                                      
Merrill Lynch South Africa Proprietary Limited                                  
Independent reporting accountants                                               
PricewaterhouseCoopers Inc                                                      
Legal advisor to MMI                                                            
Edward Nathan Sonnenbergs Inc.                                                  
Legal advisor to KTH                                                            
Webber Wetzel Attorneys                                                         
Transaction and debt advisors to KTH                                            
Afterguard Services Proprietary Limited                                         
Independent expert                                                              
Ernst & Young                                                                   
Date: 18/05/2012 07:05:09 Produced by the JSE SENS Department.                  
The SENS service is an information dissemination service administered by the    
JSE Limited (`JSE`). The JSE does not, whether expressly, tacitly or            
implicitly, represent, warrant or in any way guarantee the truth, accuracy or   
completeness of the information published on SENS. The JSE, their officers,     
employees and agents accept no liability for (or in respect of) any direct,     
indirect, incidental or consequential loss or damage of any kind or nature,     
howsoever arising, from the use of SENS or the use of, or reliance on,          
information disseminated through SENS.